British philosopher (1873–1958) whose Principia Ethica (1903) named the naturalistic fallacy and argued, by the open question argument, that goodness is indefinable — making ethics autonomous and irreducible to natural science. With Russell he led the Cambridge revolt against British Idealism.
Born 1873; died 1958 — a Cambridge career of exactly the length of analytic philosophy's formation.
Principia Ethica grew out of his 1897 dissertation on the metaphysical basis of ethics and 1898 London lectures, with the last three chapters largely new material.
Editor of Mind (1921–47): the journal of the analytic establishment he helped found.
Key Contributions
The naturalistic fallacy: defining goodness in naturalistic terms — pleasure, desire, evolution — is a fallacy; ethics has its own subject matter.
The open question argument: for any proposed definition of good — for instance, that being good means being what we desire to desire — its truth remains an "open question", sensible to doubt in a way impossible for a true definition.
A Defence of Common Sense (1925): the paper listing truisms — that the earth existed for many years before his birth, that he has a body — asserting he knows them for certain, while leaving open how they are to be analysed, even radically, so long as consistent with their truth and knowability.
Moore's hands: his proof of an external world — "here is one hand" — the classic gesture of ordinary-language resistance to skepticism.
Major Works
Principia Ethica (1903) — the fallacy and the argument.
"A Defence of Common Sense" (1925) — the truisms.
"Proof of an External World" (1939) — the hands.
Influence & Reception
Russell's ally in the revolt against idealism — the two inaugurated twentieth-century analytic philosophy at Cambridge.
Wittgenstein honored him as the philosopher of the obvious; Bloomsbury took Principia's "the good is indefinable" as license for aesthetic ethics.
Metaethics still argues over the open question argument more than a century on — intuitionism, emotivism and naturalism all answering Principia.