French philosopher (1647–1706), the "super-skeptic" of Popkin's label, whose six-million-word Historical and Critical Dictionary (1697) — Cassirer's "Arsenal of the Enlightenment" — argued that reason cannot reconcile evil with one infinitely perfect God, prompting Leibniz's Theodicy, Voltaire's Candide and parts of Hume's Dialogues.
Born 18 November 1647 in Le Carla; died December 1706 in Rotterdam — a Huguenot exile, professor seduced from Catholicism and back, editor of the Republic of Letters' journals.
The Dictionary's first edition 1697, expanded 1702; the 1740 fifth edition is most cited by scholars.
Hume recommended its more metaphysical articles (Zeno, Spinoza) to Michael Ramsay in 1737 — a reading list for the century.
The Dictionary’s more metaphysical articles — on Zeno and Spinoza — were the ones Hume recommended in 1737: the skeptical canon, shelved by title.
Key Contributions
Skepticism with limits: the "superskeptic" of Popkin's crisis — yet in later works (the Dialogues of Maximus and Themistius) evidence is a reliable, only probable criterion of truth: reason not to call him a strict skeptic.
Toleration: the Philosophical Commentary on Luke 14:23 ("Compel them to enter", 1686–88) attacked persecution — no sincere rational person could find persecution evidently good, anticipating a Kant-style universality test and raising the live "Persecutor Paradox" debate.
The problem of evil: the Dictionary's "Manicheans" and "Paulicians" articles — reason cannot reconcile evil with one infinitely perfect God; the Manichean two-principle answer unanswerable by reason alone.
The critical method: the Dictionary's footnotes — correction upon correction, errata as a literary form — made doubt a reading practice.
Major Works
Philosophical Commentary (1686–88).
Historical and Critical Dictionary (1697/1702).
The second edition of 1702 expanded the Dictionary’s attack surface; the 1740 fifth edition is the scholars’ standard.
Influence & Reception
The Enlightenment read itself out of his footnotes — Leibniz, Hume, Voltaire, Rousseau and Kant all in his debt.