Persian theologian and philosopher (c. 1056–1111) whose Incoherence of the Philosophers put Avicenna's followers on trial: of twenty teachings criticized, three were condemned as apostasy. On causation he held that "the connection between what is habitually believed to be a cause and what is habitually believed to be an effect is not necessary" — denying causal necessity, not causation itself.
Born c. 1055/56 (his letters point there, rather than the 1058/59 of medieval historians); died December 1111 in Ṭūs.
At the height of the Islamic Golden Age he held the prestigious Baghdad Niẓāmiyya professorship — then abandoned it in 1095.
His autobiography, Deliverance from Error (al-Munqidh min al-ḍalāl), claims two years studying the philosophers and a third writing the Incoherence — an account his entry deems apologetic, since he likely met falsafa earlier under al-Juwaynī.
After pilgrimage he founded a private school and Sufi convent (khānqāh) in Ṭūs.
Key Contributions
The Incoherence: twenty teachings of the falāsifa criticized — sixteen metaphysical, four natural — none, he argued, meeting the epistemic standard of demonstration (burhān); philosophers practice taqlīd, uncritical repetition. The three condemnations as apostasy: the world's pre-eternity, God's knowing only universals, and the denial of bodily resurrection.
Causation: the seventeenth discussion denies the *necessity* of causal connection — later scholarship holds he treated occasionalism and Avicennan secondary causality as live options without committing to either, even in his final work.
Skepticism survived: his autobiographical crisis of the senses and intellect is a fully modern-seeming doubt — resolved not by proof but by "a light God cast into my chest".
Sufism: reading Sufi literature from around 1093 changed his life — beliefs alone do not secure salvation; virtuous actions do.
Major Works
The Incoherence of the Philosophers (Tahāfut al-falāsifa) — the prosecution.
Deliverance from Error — the intellectual autobiography.
The Revival of the Religious Sciences (Iḥyāʾ) — the summa of practical religion.
Influence & Reception
Averroes answered him in the Incoherence of the Incoherence — the dispute that frames Arabic philosophy for the Latin Middle Ages.
His occasionalist reading of causality reached Descartes' century through Latin transmission.
Sufism's philosophical standing in Sunni Islam is largely his settlement.