The moral evaluation of organized violence between just war's two sets of criteria — jus ad bellum (just cause, legitimate authority, right intention, reasonable prospects, proportionality, last resort) and jus in bello (discrimination, proportionality, necessity) — against realists who "deny that morality applies at all once the guns strike up" and pacifists who hold no plausible moral theory could permit war's exceptional horrors.
Branch
Political philosophy, ethics
Originated
Augustine and Aquinas; codified 1625
Key Figures
Grotius, Walzer, McMahan, Rodin
Definition
Just war theory seeks a middle path between realism and pacifism — the labels jus ad bellum and jus in bello "unfortunately obscurantist", but serviceable shorthand.
More recent additions: jus post bellum and jus ex bello — the aftermath and the exit.
Origins & Development
The scholastic inheritance codified by Grotius (1625); international law's Geneva lineage.
Walzer's Just and Unjust Wars (1977) — the traditionalist anchor for the modern debate.
Main Positions & Arguments
Traditionalists vs. revisionists: traditionalists led by international law and Walzer; revisionists — McMahan, Rodin — contesting combatant equality, civilian immunity, and national defence.
The responsibility dilemma: just combatants fighting unjustly ordered wars — the revisionists' sharpest tool.
The bloodless invasion: if a victim state could win without killing, may it still kill? The proportionality test's edge case.
Objections
To realism: the just war tradition's persistence; to pacifism: the aggressive war it cannot resist; to the tradition: the revisionists' charge that combatant equality licenses injustice.
The jus ad bellum list reads as six gates every resort to force must pass — a checklist Walzer defended as moral common sense, and revisionists dismantle clause by clause.
Combatant equality — the soldier’s symmetrical license regardless of side — is the tradition’s load-bearing wall and the revisionists’ first target.