"Equality of what?" — Sen's question, with seven conceptions of distributive equality as answers, and his own: orient distribution around "capabilities to achieve functionings", since resourcist theories are "fetishistic" about means rather than what people gain from them.
Branch
Political philosophy
Originated
the levellers; theorized 1971–
Key Figures
Sen, Anderson, Rawls, Parfit
Definition
Distributive: what should be equalized — welfare, resources, capabilities, opportunity?
Relational: a society just when "individuals within it relate to one another as equals" — the site of justice society, not distributions.
Origins & Development
Rawls's difference principle re-founded the debate; Sen's capabilities redirected its currency.
Since the late 1990s, relational egalitarianism — Anderson, Miller, Scanlon, Scheffler, Wolff, Young — as the major rival to distributive accounts.
Main Positions & Arguments
Luck egalitarianism: unjust to be worse off "through no fault or choice of your own" — compensating brute luck, not option luck.
Anderson's critique (1999): the responsibility criterion is "harsh", abandoning people responsible for their own misery; compensation for involuntary disadvantage stigmatizes, resting on pity.
Prioritarianism: Parfit 1997 — benefiting people matters more the worse off they are; equality a relational value while priority is not, though both agree the best fixed-sum distribution is equal.
Sufficiency: Frankfurt — "that each should have enough", the non-egalitarian alternative.
Objections
The harshness objection to luck egalitarianism; the separatism worry for relational accounts — what do they say about distributions?
The seven currencies of Section 3 — welfare, resources, capabilities among them — are the answers distributive egalitarians give to Sen’s question, and the relational turn refuses them all as misplacements of justice’s site.
Capabilities — adequate nourishment, good health, the things a person manages to do or be — aim the currency at lives actually lived, Sen’s answer to the fetishism charge.