Responsibility attributed to a unified group agent — distinguished from shared responsibility distributed among members — with Peter French arguing collective blame is non-distributive while cautioning that members may still individually warrant blame.
Branch
Ethics, social philosophy
Originated
debated from the 1990s
Key Figures
French, Gilbert, Bratman, Hess
Definition
The group as bearer: a "we" that did it, over and above the members who did.
Membership's moral weight: Narveson's four group types (voluntary, involuntary-in/voluntary-out...) with responsibility diminishing down the list.
Origins & Development
The postwar and post-corporate-scandal debates pushed the question from metaphor to theory.
Kovach (2006) proposes "moral alignment" for ethnic groups; Raikka (1997) even holds dissenters blameworthy when they still support the system.
Main Positions & Arguments
Corporate responsibility: French (1984) — organizations with decision-making procedures ("conglomerate collectivities") as apt sites; Hess (2014) — collectives with free will via "reasons-responsive mechanisms"; Shockley (2007) — Enron's norms exerting "coordinating control".
Shared intention: Bratman (1999, 2014) — interlocking intentions and "meshing subplans", no collective mind; Gilbert's plural-subject account grounded in joint commitment; Tuomela's "we intentions".
Objections
The distributivist's challenge: guilt is paradigmatically personal — can the sum become a new bearer? The voluntariness problem: inherited memberships and un-chosen states.
Gilbert’s joint commitment analysis gives the group its owe-ings: parties to a commitment are blameworthy for what the body does, on grounds unavailable to accidental collections of strangers.
Bratman’s planner’s model stays individualist to the end — shared intention is a web of I-intentions, not a group mind — keeping responsibility’s ledger personal while acknowledging the web’s structure.
The Enron case — Shockley’s "coordinating control" — shows the stakes: when norms and incentives steer thousands, blaming only the individuals leaves the machine itself untouched.