"Perhaps the most pursued disagreement in the literature": whether beauty is objective — in the object's qualities, as the ancients held — or "exists merely in the mind which contemplates them", as Hume wrote.
Branch
Aesthetics
Originated
antiquity; modern debate 1739–1790
Key Figures
Plato, Aristotle, Hume, Kant
Definition
The classical conception: an arrangement of integral parts into a coherent whole — according to proportion, harmony and symmetry.
Aristotle's Metaphysics lists "order and symmetry and definiteness" as the chief forms of the beautiful — embodied in Polykleitos's Canon and Vitruvius's architecture.
Origins & Development
Ancient and medieval accounts generally located beauty in the object — Augustine holding that things delight us because they are beautiful, not vice versa.
The eighteenth century's subjectivist turn — Hume and Kant — produced the "antinomy of taste" both then tried to resolve.
Main Positions & Arguments
Hume's standard of taste: the joint verdict of true critics — those with "strong sense, united to delicate sentiment, improved by practice, and perfected by comparison".
Kant's judgments of taste: disinterested and subjectively grounded yet claiming universal assent — the beautiful between the agreeable and the good.
Burke against proportion: flowers and birds of wildly varying proportions are all beautiful — and beauty as qualities that "cause love, or some passion similar to it", distinct from the sublime.
Objections
To classical proportion: Burke's varying examples; to subjectivism: the normativity of taste — why argue about what we merely like?
The twentieth century largely displaced beauty for the sublime, the interesting, and the avant-garde — the entry tracks what the discipline lost and what it fled.