Phoenix feather is one of the three wand cores that the wandmaker Garrick Ollivander judged worthy of his wands. J.K. Rowling's wand-lore writing on the official site records his conclusion that only unicorn hair, dragon heartstring and phoenix feather, the three Supreme Cores, produce wands worthy of his name. Of the three, "this is the rarest core type": phoenix feathers are "capable of the greatest range of magic, though they may take longer than either unicorn or dragon cores" to reveal it. The earlier stub's "great potential" and "choosy allegiance" survive in that record; its "brother wands rare" point belongs to one specific pair of feathers from Fawkes, documented on the sibling Phoenix Feather page, and this entry keeps the two records distinct.
The writing, presented as Ollivander's own notes, fixes the core's character in a few sentences. Phoenix feathers are capable of the greatest range of magic, though they may take longer than either unicorn or dragon cores to reveal it. They "show the most initiative, sometimes acting of their own accord, a quality that many witches and wizards dislike." Phoenix feather wands are "always the pickiest when it comes to potential owners," because the creature the feathers come from is "one of the most independent and detached in the world" — the Phoenix. The summary line matches the stub's "choosy": these wands are "the hardest to tame and to personalise, and their allegiance is usually hard won."
The same page explains the core's standing. Having watched his father work with inferior materials, Ollivander resolved to use only the finest cores, and his three Supreme Cores are the result. Each wand is a composite of wood, core and owner, so the record treats these as tendencies, not rules; the writing warns that one element's tendencies may counterbalance or outweigh another's. The site's background page is Wand Cores and Woods.
Unlike a potion or a book artefact, this item's canon is wand-lore: the description lives in Rowling's supplementary writing rather than a single novel scene, and this page does not invent one. The book-level fact is older: the Lexicon records that Harry's holly-and-phoenix-feather wand was chosen at Ollivanders in Philosopher's Stone chapter 5, and that its core came from Fawkes. Named owners appear in the official feature "What does your Harry Potter Wand say about you?": Harry Potter and Lord Voldemort among wizards with phoenix feather cores, along with Silvanus Kettleburn. That feature draws on the wand choices of the site's visitors, so its owner list is official material rather than a book passage, and it is reported here as such.
The core's rarest documented consequence is the brother-wand effect: when two wands share a core from the same creature, forcing them to duel produces Prior Incantato, the golden-web reverse-spell effect of Goblet of Fire. That story belongs to Fawkes's two feathers and is recorded on the Phoenix Feather page. The site's records for the other two Supreme Cores, Unicorn Hair Core and Dragon Heartstring Core, and for the separately documented Thestral Hair Core, which is not one of Ollivander's three, are distinct entities and should not be merged with this one.